Loading...
Date of Incident
17/10/2026
Country
Scotland
Area
Route
Activity
Trad rock climbing
When
Ascending
Injury
Serious injury requiring medical treatment
Incident
I was climbing the route using lead rope solo. The route is E1 5b, therefore it was tricky. It started out with a well protected beginning, then a bold ran out mid section, then a resting ledge before the crux. Due to the run out, a fall from that resting ledge would result in a ground fall. However, there was a crack there to place pieces in. Yet that means that if that piece were to blow, you would hit the ground before the piece below would catch. At the time of climbing this, I had come from a background of unroped climbing therefore my sense of danger was almost erased. I didn’t recognize the seriousness of what I was committing to, I had placed a marginal DMM number 2 nut and went for the crux. The next issue came in how I went about the moves. It was moves that weren’t too easy, combined with the air underneath my feet from the fact that it was just over a roof, I was hesitant. This culminated in a move which I fell on, where you had to dyno off a good crimp into an okay-ish sloper. Despite this being a v3/v4 dyno which I could very well do in a gym, the fact that I had lots of air and realized that my piece was marginal had me hesitate. My arms got pumped out and my eventual dyno attempt was insufficient and I fell, the marginal piece blew, the piece below that couldn’t catch me and I hit the ground. It was approx a 10-11m fall. Miraculously all spine fractures were stable, yet my entire thoracic spine was fractured.
Lessons
1) The most obvious lesson is how placing gear is the bread and butter of any extensions of trad climbing (lead rope solo, mixed climbing, alpinism etc…) . I was so focused on getting my lead rope solo system perfect, but it didn’t even have the chance to catch me because my gear blew. In other words, nothing mattered because my placements were bad.
2) Just because I could have pulled through the moves doesn’t mean I can lead it. Not only does the route need lots of trad experience for the ‘trad sense’, it also called for a stronger mind that didn’t hesitate on the dyno. Essentially, I was punching above my weightclass.
3) Get cams. I feel like smaller cams could have fit really well in that crack in retrospect. Perhaps big hexes (which I had) have their role, but small cams have their role too.
4) Actually make sure to have experience before going out alone. I feel like my past successes on unroped ‘big climbs ’ in Scotland and in UAE tricked me into thinking I was better at trad than I am. It seems to me that every discipline of climbing essentially requires a feeling of ‘starting from zero.’ While perhaps I was good at ‘big mountain stuff’, I needed to start from zero in trad.
5) If forced to go out alone, be conservative. The reason why I went out alone was because of the ‘entry-level job paradox’ in finding a climbing partner. Perhaps I would have been resourceful rather than reckless if I had spent that day running laps on severes or HS’s rather than E1s. I had done the same in my first Scottish winter, where the bulk of my initial experience in winter was solo and self taught, but very conservative, between grade I-II. It was a very large oversight for me not to follow that blueprint.
Causes
Slip, trip or fall, Inadequate equipment, clothing or footwear, Equipment failure
Anonymous?
No
Reported By
N/A, was solo
Wearing Helmets?
Yes
Rescue Services Involved?
Not sure, a bystander called an ambulance. I’m a foreigner so I don’t know how it works here
Author
Zein Ionescu
1 November 2026 at 16:43:12
For more advice and guidance on good practices visit BMC skills
All reports are self-submitted and have not been edited by the BMC in any way, so please keep an open mind regarding the lessons and causes of each incident or near-miss.
If you have a concern regarding this report please contact us at incidentreports@thebmc.co.uk